WINBECK Complete Symphonies
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Genre:
Orchestral
Label: TYXart
Magazine Review Date: 03/2020
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 292
Mastering:
DDD
Catalogue Number: TXA17091

Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Symphony No 1, 'Tu Solus' |
Heinz Winbeck, Composer
Bruce Weinberger, Tenor saxophone Muhai Tang, Conductor Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks |
Symphony No 2 |
Heinz Winbeck, Composer
Dennis Russell Davies, Conductor ORF Vienna Symphony Orchestra |
Symphony No 3 |
Heinz Winbeck, Composer
Berlin German Symphony Orchestra Christel Borchers, Alto Mathias Husmann, Conductor Udo Samel, Narrator |
Symphony No 4, 'De Profundis' |
Heinz Winbeck, Composer
Bonn Beethoven Orchestra Christel Borchers, Alto Dennis Russell Davies, Conductor Günter Binge, Baritone Werner Buchin, Countertenor Wolf Euba, Narrator |
Symphony No 5, 'Jetzt und in der Stunde' |
Heinz Winbeck, Composer
Berlin German Symphony Orchestra Dennis Russell Davies, Conductor |
Author: Richard Whitehouse
That Heinz Winbeck (1946-2019) was relatively unknown outside his native Germany only confirms the lack of recognition accorded Austro-German symphonism in the post-war era, to which this set of his symphonies makes handsome while regrettably posthumous amends.
Such quirkily subversive pieces as Entgegengesang (1973) or Lenau-Fantasien (1979) gave little inkling Winbeck might embrace this most historically loaded of genres, yet he did just that with his First Symphony (1983). Inspired by the fate of Sophie Scholl, along with that of the White Rose resistance in the Second World War, its Mahlerian (in impact if not in length) confrontation between unmediated violence and rapt eloquence was subsequently resolved in revision with a return to the opening music and followed by a conclusion of numbing finality.
Muhai Tang presides over a reading of this piece that is more propulsive than the admirable Wergo account and with far better sound. Dennis Russell Davies takes over for the Second Symphony (1987) – emotionally more equivocal in its trajectory from ominous expectancy, via mounting agitation, to a searching introspection itself denied by the percussive fusillade at the end. If this piece centres (aesthetically rather than stylistically) on the Romanticism of Schumann, the Third Symphony (1988) looks to Berg in its fractured expression articulated through poetry by Georg Trakl; cannily, his final poem (the work’s subtitle) is never set but instead recited toward the work’s climax, prior to a closing fantasia of fraught irresolution. A culmination in all respects, the Fourth Symphony (1993) sets further Trakl alongside Psalm 130 for an 80 minute work that ranges as though a Bosch-like fresco over Germanic culture in time of crisis, its seven continuous sections given symphonic cohesion by an underlying symmetry that tempers rhetorical overkill and makes possible the intriguingly oblique close.
After four such works in just over a decade, some 15 years passed before the Fifth Symphony (2009). Believing himself unable to complete the finale of Bruckner’s Ninth, Winbeck chose instead to embody themes from this torso within a piece of comparable scale and intensity. Its three movements unfold as a cumulative sequence towards a lengthy coda where Bruckner’s chorale hovers, vision-like, before fading into silence; in the process suggesting a ‘third way’, between the atrophied poles of modernism and minimalism, that Western music could pursue.
No texts or translations, but Thorsten Preuss contributes an extensive overview of each piece, with artwork by Winbeck’s friend Engelbert Hilbich adorning each disc. Quite a coup for the innovative TYXart label, and a mandatory purchase for open-minded listeners everywhere.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.

Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.