Ligeti: Instrumental Works
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: György Ligeti
Label: Wergo
Magazine Review Date: 11/1989
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 54
Mastering:
ADD
Catalogue Number: WER60161-50
Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Continuum |
György Ligeti, Composer
Antoniette Vischer, Harpsichord György Ligeti, Composer |
(10) Pieces |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer South West German Radio Wind Quintet |
Organ Study No. 1, 'Harmonies' |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer Zsigmond Szathmáry, Organ |
Organ Study No. 2, 'Coulée' |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer Zsigmond Szathmáry, Organ |
Volumina |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer Karl-Erik Welin, Organ |
Artikulation |
György Ligeti, Composer
Cornelius Cardew, Tape operator Gottfried Michael Koenig, Tape operator György Ligeti, Tape operator György Ligeti, Composer |
Glissandi |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer György Ligeti, Tape operator |
Author:
If it's Continuum you're after, hard luck. Ligeti, perhaps tempting fate, specifies that the piece should not last longer than four minutes. On BIS Eva Nordwall dashes home in 3'29'' by dint of leaving out large numbers of notes; Antoinette Vischer, at 3'36'', plays all the notes, only to be scuppered by Wergo snipping off the first 12 bars. Vischer's is a tremendous performance, by the way, and can be heard intact on the original Wergo LP (nla); but you still have to put up with the unaccountable absence of the left-hand part for most of page 9. Nor, I'm afraid, can I wax lyrical about the performance of the Wind Quintet pieces. Intonation is dicey from the start, not all the players are up to Ligeti's more extreme demands, and there is distortion on the recording.
The rest of the programme is slightly more successful. The electronic pieces are hardly vintage Ligeti—they both end inconsequentially, for one thing—and the sound-quality is limited presumably by the fact that the tapes are now more than 30 years old; but there are some inventive, playful effects here, which anyone interested in the electronic scene will enjoy getting to know.
The organ pieces come off best of all. Of the two studies, ''Harmonies'', with its reduced wind pressure, gives the entrancing impression of playing on an orchestra of pitched jet engines, and ''Coulee'' (Flowing) is a companion to Continuum in its stroboscopic Op Art effects. Volumina is in a sense uncharacteristically crude, but Karl-Erik Welin chooses suitably apocalyptic registrations and the conclusion, with forlorn sounds evaporating as the motor is switched off, is haunting.
Not one of the more successful Wergo/Ligeti discs overall then, but worth selective investigation.'
The rest of the programme is slightly more successful. The electronic pieces are hardly vintage Ligeti—they both end inconsequentially, for one thing—and the sound-quality is limited presumably by the fact that the tapes are now more than 30 years old; but there are some inventive, playful effects here, which anyone interested in the electronic scene will enjoy getting to know.
The organ pieces come off best of all. Of the two studies, ''Harmonies'', with its reduced wind pressure, gives the entrancing impression of playing on an orchestra of pitched jet engines, and ''Coulee'' (Flowing) is a companion to Continuum in its stroboscopic Op Art effects. Volumina is in a sense uncharacteristically crude, but Karl-Erik Welin chooses suitably apocalyptic registrations and the conclusion, with forlorn sounds evaporating as the motor is switched off, is haunting.
Not one of the more successful Wergo/Ligeti discs overall then, but worth selective investigation.'
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.
Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
SubscribeGramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.