Gay/Britten The Beggar's Opera
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: John Gay
Genre:
Opera
Label: Argo
Magazine Review Date: 9/1993
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 108
Mastering:
DDD
Catalogue Number: 436 850-2ZHO2
Tracks:
| Composition | Artist Credit |
|---|---|
| (The) Beggar's Opera |
John Gay, Composer
Aldeburgh Festival Choir Aldeburgh Festival Orchestra Ann Murray, Polly, Mezzo soprano Anne Collins, Mrs Peachum, Mezzo soprano Christopher Gillett, Filch, Tenor Declan Mulholland, Beggar John Gay, Composer John Rawnsley, Lockit, Baritone Nuala Willis, Mrs Trapes, Mezzo soprano Philip Langridge, Macheath, Tenor Robert Lloyd, Peachum, Baritone Steuart Bedford, Conductor Yvonne Kenny, Lucy, Soprano |
Author:
''Not a 'sport' among Britten's operas but an integral part of the totality of theatrical work, from Paul Bunyan to Death in Venice'': Donald Mitchell puts the claim well, and this first recording supports it all the way. The Beggar's Opera was Britten's new work for the English Opera Group in 1948 and had its premiere at the Arts Theatre, Cambridge. There were joyful performances in subsequent years at Sadler's Wells. but revivals have been comparatively rare. Whether on doctrinal grounds (a preference for Gay-without-gloss, the folk opera naked and unashamed), or whether out of a notion that being an arrangement, it hardly constitutes a 'work', Op. 43 has had less than its due.
Everything here is well set-up to make amends. The 12 players forming the chamber orchestra are excellent individually (and each is provided with special opportunities) and they respond sensitively to Steuart Bedford's direction. With Harry Christophers as chorus master and Michael Geliot in charge of dialogue, the singer-actors are expertly assisted, and Michael Woolcock's production is vivid without being obtrusive. There is always a problem over the matching of speaking voices with the singing, and another over the accents ('common', 'posh', 'mummerset' or whatever). Occasional anomalies persist here. Mrs Peachum's singing voice is splendidly forthcoming, her speaking a trifle reticent, and Lucy clearly has been brought up 'posh' though her dad is decidedly 'common'. At the very least, the speech causes no embarrassment; at best it is spirited, and the full-fathom-five depth of Robert Lloyd's Peachum gives profound pleasure. The singing is probably as good as it should be, in many of the numbers, character matters more than beauty of tone, though a more consistent steadiness of voice-production would not come amiss.
All scores have a reckoning'' as the Beggar remarks, and finally it is to Britten's score that one has to return when making a recommendation.The Beggar's Opera can also be obtained on records in very different forms. There is the 'authentic' version with the Broadside Band under Jeremy Barlow (Hyperion, 1/92), highly unattractive too. The starry version under Richard Bonynge (Decca 5/91) is more entertaining, but here the gloss is thick and the enrichment of musical interest, when it occurs, scarcely stretches the imagination. Britten's work is of a different order altogether. It is not mere cleverness, though the sheer ingenuities of rhythm, counterpoint, harmony and orchestration keep the ear fully occupied and delighted. Much more, the process is one of absorption and re-creation, sometimes fierce or poignant, sometimes magical in its loveliness (the use of the chorus in ''Cease your funning'', for example). The marvel is that the tunes themselves, so far from rejecting Britten's treatment as the body might reject a transplant, seem to find themselves in their element. The recording fills a gap in respect of Gay's masterpiece as surely as it fills another in the Britten oeuvre.'
Everything here is well set-up to make amends. The 12 players forming the chamber orchestra are excellent individually (and each is provided with special opportunities) and they respond sensitively to Steuart Bedford's direction. With Harry Christophers as chorus master and Michael Geliot in charge of dialogue, the singer-actors are expertly assisted, and Michael Woolcock's production is vivid without being obtrusive. There is always a problem over the matching of speaking voices with the singing, and another over the accents ('common', 'posh', 'mummerset' or whatever). Occasional anomalies persist here. Mrs Peachum's singing voice is splendidly forthcoming, her speaking a trifle reticent, and Lucy clearly has been brought up 'posh' though her dad is decidedly 'common'. At the very least, the speech causes no embarrassment; at best it is spirited, and the full-fathom-five depth of Robert Lloyd's Peachum gives profound pleasure. The singing is probably as good as it should be, in many of the numbers, character matters more than beauty of tone, though a more consistent steadiness of voice-production would not come amiss.
All scores have a reckoning'' as the Beggar remarks, and finally it is to Britten's score that one has to return when making a recommendation.
Gay/Britten The Beggar's Opera
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.
Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.