Coates Orchestral Works
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Eric Coates
Label: British Light Music
Magazine Review Date: 1/1994
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 73
Mastering:
DDD
Catalogue Number: 8 223445
Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Calling All Workers |
Eric Coates, Composer
Adrian Leaper, Conductor Bratislava Radio Symphony Orchestra Eric Coates, Composer |
Cinderella |
Eric Coates, Composer
Adrian Leaper, Conductor Bratislava Radio Symphony Orchestra Eric Coates, Composer |
(The) Dam Busters |
Eric Coates, Composer
Adrian Leaper, Conductor Bratislava Radio Symphony Orchestra Eric Coates, Composer |
London Suite |
Eric Coates, Composer
Adrian Leaper, Conductor Bratislava Radio Symphony Orchestra Eric Coates, Composer |
London Again |
Eric Coates, Composer
Adrian Leaper, Conductor Bratislava Radio Symphony Orchestra Eric Coates, Composer |
(The) Merrymakers |
Eric Coates, Composer
Adrian Leaper, Conductor Bratislava Radio Symphony Orchestra Eric Coates, Composer |
(The) Selfish Giant |
Eric Coates, Composer
Adrian Leaper, Conductor Bratislava Radio Symphony Orchestra Eric Coates, Composer |
Author: Andrew Lamb
If Eric Coates scarcely needs the pioneering efforts of Marco Polo's British Light Music Series, the series would equally be incomplete without him. Sticking for the most part to well-worn territory, the result will provide joy for anyone—in Bratislava or wherever—who may be new to Coates's music, and it offers uncommonly generous and informative notes by Tim McDonald.
For the most part the marches come off particularly well, with ''Knightsbridge'' and ''Oxford Street'' bouncing along quite splendidly. Perhaps the one disappointment among them is The Dam Busters. Maybe one should not condemn Adrian Leaper for attempting a different approach to such a familiar piece, but whether his pulling around of tempo and dynamics fully succeeds is more questionable. As elsewhere in the series, too, Leaper often misses the snap and precision of the best conductors of this sort of music. Compare, for instance, the sluggish start to The Merrymakers Overture with the crispness of Mackerras or, even more markedly, his turgid ''Covent Garden'' tarantella with that of Groves in the same Classics for Pleasure compilation.
In more restrained mood, Cinderella is quite charmingly done, as is The Selfish Giant—a piece in markedly similar vein that is, I believe, appearing on CD for the first time. Where Leaper scores most, though, is surely in the ''Langham Place'' 'elegie' movement of the London Again suite. The movement pays homage not only to the BBC but also to the Queen's Hall, where Coates played as a young orchestral musician. The Elgarian nobilmente of Leaper's performance is surely just what Coates set out to capture.
The Classics for Pleasure collection remains first choice, then, but admiration for the enterprise of this Marco Polo series remains almost unbounded.'
For the most part the marches come off particularly well, with ''Knightsbridge'' and ''Oxford Street'' bouncing along quite splendidly. Perhaps the one disappointment among them is The Dam Busters. Maybe one should not condemn Adrian Leaper for attempting a different approach to such a familiar piece, but whether his pulling around of tempo and dynamics fully succeeds is more questionable. As elsewhere in the series, too, Leaper often misses the snap and precision of the best conductors of this sort of music. Compare, for instance, the sluggish start to The Merrymakers Overture with the crispness of Mackerras or, even more markedly, his turgid ''Covent Garden'' tarantella with that of Groves in the same Classics for Pleasure compilation.
In more restrained mood, Cinderella is quite charmingly done, as is The Selfish Giant—a piece in markedly similar vein that is, I believe, appearing on CD for the first time. Where Leaper scores most, though, is surely in the ''Langham Place'' 'elegie' movement of the London Again suite. The movement pays homage not only to the BBC but also to the Queen's Hall, where Coates played as a young orchestral musician. The Elgarian nobilmente of Leaper's performance is surely just what Coates set out to capture.
The Classics for Pleasure collection remains first choice, then, but admiration for the enterprise of this Marco Polo series remains almost unbounded.'
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.
Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
SubscribeGramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.