Bach Early Cantatas
A rewarding inaugural disc in this latest mini-series from the Purcells
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Johann Sebastian Bach
Genre:
Vocal
Label: Chaconne
Magazine Review Date: 5/2005
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 77
Mastering:
Stereo
DDD
Catalogue Number: CHAN0715
Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Cantata No. 4, 'Christ lag in Todesbanden' |
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer
Andrew Watts, Bassoon Anthony Robson, Oboe Charles Daniels, Tenor Clare Salaman, Viola Emma Kirkby, Soprano Jane Rogers, Viola Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer Marion Scott, Recorder Michael Chance, Alto Peter Harvey, Bass Purcell Qt Rachel Beckett, Recorder Richard Campbell, Viola da gamba |
Cantata No. 131, 'Aus der Tiefen rufe ich, Herr, z |
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer
Andrew Watts, Bassoon Anthony Robson, Oboe Charles Daniels, Tenor Clare Salaman, Viola Emma Kirkby, Soprano Jane Rogers, Viola Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer Marion Scott, Recorder Michael Chance, Alto Peter Harvey, Bass Purcell Qt Rachel Beckett, Recorder Richard Campbell, Viola da gamba |
Cantata No. 106, 'Gottes Zeit ist die allerbeste Z |
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer
Andrew Watts, Bassoon Anthony Robson, Oboe Charles Daniels, Tenor Clare Salaman, Viola Emma Kirkby, Soprano Jane Rogers, Viola Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer Marion Scott, Recorder Michael Chance, Alto Peter Harvey, Bass Purcell Qt Rachel Beckett, Recorder Richard Campbell, Viola da gamba |
Cantata No. 196, '(Der) Herr denket an uns' |
Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer
Andrew Watts, Bassoon Anthony Robson, Oboe Charles Daniels, Tenor Clare Salaman, Viola Emma Kirkby, Soprano Jane Rogers, Viola Johann Sebastian Bach, Composer Marion Scott, Recorder Michael Chance, Alto Peter Harvey, Bass Purcell Qt Rachel Beckett, Recorder Richard Campbell, Viola da gamba |
Author: Jonathan Freeman-Attwood
These cantatas date from Bach’s brief tenure as organist in Muhlhausen (1707-08) when the composer was barely in his 20s. Remarkable for their individuality, each of the four works is conceived on the foundations of past traditions alongside current conventions which the young Bach had assimilated into his creative repository since birth. The Purcell Quartet and their distinguished single-voice ‘chorus’ simply and refreshingly take as they find by relishing the intimate and heart-warming potential of reflective devotion which Christ lag in Todesbanden and Gottes Zeit (or Actus tragicus), the two best-known works here, offer.
Throughout, the mixed group of singers and instrumentalists provide a lightness of touch where others might sink into despondent purplish textures. There is certainly less of the smouldering rhetoric of the rich palette of Continental ensembles and yet rarely has the stark trajectory from loneliness to hope been so intimately realised in Christ lag – Bach’s first real masterpiece. Peter Harvey under-characterises the theatricality of verse 6 (‘the night of sin is vanished’ is far too safe) but there are few other missed opportunities here.
The line is ‘led’ by Emma Kirkby (though leadership is perhaps not a straight-forward concept in this cohesive ensemble genre). Hers may not be a timbre one associates readily with Bach – whatever that can mean – but this is a performance of great musical versatility, a prima inter pares, who shifts her lyrical instincts readily from contemplative yearning to joyous extroversion. The distinctive Michael Chance has a tendency to stick out uncomfortably in one-to-a-part the ensembles but he makes a poignant contribution in his duet with Kirkby in No 4, if rather less so in Actus tragicus, altogether the least potently realised of the cantatas.
Whilst the austere Aus der Tiefen settles less well than the others (the imploring quality of Philippe Herreweghe’s collective forces adds up to rather more), this is still a telling account which exudes independent thinking, captured in the heavily-imaged solo oboe in ‘So du willt’ where Anthony Robson splendidly interpolates and encircles the vocal lines with a life-force (and life-line) of God-given salvation. Charles Daniels’s sensitive supplication, ‘Meele seele’, from the same work is evocatively under-pinned by Robert Woolley’s fine organ realisation. The succinct No 196 caps an excellent opening disc in this mini-series with its beautifully languid opening Sinfonia and glorious peroration. Evidence more of a genius made than in the making.
Throughout, the mixed group of singers and instrumentalists provide a lightness of touch where others might sink into despondent purplish textures. There is certainly less of the smouldering rhetoric of the rich palette of Continental ensembles and yet rarely has the stark trajectory from loneliness to hope been so intimately realised in Christ lag – Bach’s first real masterpiece. Peter Harvey under-characterises the theatricality of verse 6 (‘the night of sin is vanished’ is far too safe) but there are few other missed opportunities here.
The line is ‘led’ by Emma Kirkby (though leadership is perhaps not a straight-forward concept in this cohesive ensemble genre). Hers may not be a timbre one associates readily with Bach – whatever that can mean – but this is a performance of great musical versatility, a prima inter pares, who shifts her lyrical instincts readily from contemplative yearning to joyous extroversion. The distinctive Michael Chance has a tendency to stick out uncomfortably in one-to-a-part the ensembles but he makes a poignant contribution in his duet with Kirkby in No 4, if rather less so in Actus tragicus, altogether the least potently realised of the cantatas.
Whilst the austere Aus der Tiefen settles less well than the others (the imploring quality of Philippe Herreweghe’s collective forces adds up to rather more), this is still a telling account which exudes independent thinking, captured in the heavily-imaged solo oboe in ‘So du willt’ where Anthony Robson splendidly interpolates and encircles the vocal lines with a life-force (and life-line) of God-given salvation. Charles Daniels’s sensitive supplication, ‘Meele seele’, from the same work is evocatively under-pinned by Robert Woolley’s fine organ realisation. The succinct No 196 caps an excellent opening disc in this mini-series with its beautifully languid opening Sinfonia and glorious peroration. Evidence more of a genius made than in the making.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.
Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
SubscribeGramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.