Zimmermann (Die) Soldaten
One of the Sixties’ most remarkable works in a searing 1989 production from Stuttgart
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Bernd Alois Zimmermann
Genre:
Opera
Label: Arthaus Musik
Magazine Review Date: 8/2002
Media Format: Digital Versatile Disc
Media Runtime: 111
Catalogue Number: 100 270

Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
(Die) Soldaten |
Bernd Alois Zimmermann, Composer
Alois Treml, Obrist Bernd Alois Zimmermann, Composer Bernhard Kontarsky, Conductor Elsie Maurer, Stolzius' Mother Grace Hoffman, Wesner's Mother, Mezzo soprano Guy Renard, Pirzel Helmut Holzapfel, Young Officer 3, Tenor Jerrold van der Schaaf, Young Count Johannes Eidloth, Young Officer 1, Tenor Karl-Friedrich Dürr, Eisenhardt Klaus Hirte, Haudy, Tenor Mark Munkittrick, Wesener Michael Ebbecke, Stolzius, Bass Milagr Vargas, Charlotte Nancy Shade, Marie Raymond Wolansky, Mary, Baritone Robert Wörle, Young Officer 2, Tenor Stuttgart State Opera Chorus Stuttgart State Opera Orchestra Ursula Koszut, Countess de la Roche William Cochran, Desportes, Tenor |
Author:
The musical merits of this production of Die Soldaten have been set forth in these pages before in the review of Teldec’s studio recording taken from the same production; suffice to say I have a more positive view of this enormously problematic work’s stature. I was impressed by a televised broadcast some 10 years ago or so of Harry Kupfer’s Stuttgart production‚ so its appearance on DVD is extremely welcome.
Bernhard Kontarsky’s shaping of the alternately coruscating and black dramatic score is splendid and there are no weak links in the cast. In the central role of Marie‚ Nancy Shade is sweetly flighty in the first two acts‚ showing off her vocal mettle in the agitated solo at the end of Act 1 (menacingly intercut here with images of her wouldbe seducer‚ Desportes‚ and the army closing in on her). After romping with Desportes – a nicely turned characterisation of the strutting womaniser by William Cochran – her descent into the gutter reduces her role almost to that of a prop (bedecked in ever gaudier‚ darker dresses) as her erstwhile fiancé‚ Stolzius‚ and others take over as the main protagonists.
All the characters‚ major and minor‚ are finely drawn although necessarily some seem more like caricatures: Mark Munkittrick’s Wesener‚ Marie’s father‚ whose ambiguous attitude towards her suitors Desportes and Stolzius sets up the tragedy; Michael Ebbecke as the simpering‚ lovelorn Stolzius‚ who turns into the suicidal avenger of Marie’s ruin; Klaus Hirte as the grotesque Haudy; and Ursula Koszut as the Countess‚ who vainly offers Marie a chance of escape – and the opera’s only truly lyrical episode – in a radiant trio with Marie and her sister Charlotte (the excellent Milagro Vargas) at the close of Act 3.
On the visual side‚ the Stuttgart production is extremely well shot‚ Kupfer’s fast moving‚ splitstage realisation brilliantly captured by Hans Hulscher’s film. The use of closeups‚ shot from a variety of angles‚ is telling and wellplanned‚ though fullstage views are used throughout to catch as much of the often teeming action as possible. Kupfer’s lighting of this dark tale was a crucial element‚ and the more nightmarish scenes take place in semidarkness which does not always translate well onscreen. Similarly‚ the multimedia first scene of Act 4 almost overwhelms the video form. Die Soldaten cries out for cinematic reproduction visually‚ but this film is a tremendous record of a stunning‚ if deeply disturbing‚ theatrical experience.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.

Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.