Wagner Götterdämmerung
Shorn of the visuals, this Ring finale doesn’t remain recommendable
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Richard Wagner
Genre:
Opera
Label: Naxos
Magazine Review Date: 8/2007
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 258
Mastering:
Stereo
DDD
Catalogue Number: 8 660179/82
Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
(Der) Ring des Nibelungen: Part 4, 'Götterdämmerung' |
Richard Wagner, Composer
Albert Bonnema, Siegfried, Tenor Eva-Maria Westbroek, Gutrune, Soprano Franz-Josef Kapellmann, Alberich Helga Rós Indridadóttir, Woglinde, Soprano Hernan Iturralde, Gunther Janet Collins, Flosshilde, Mezzo soprano Janet Collins, Flosshilde, Mezzo soprano Janet Collins, First Norn, Mezzo soprano Janet Collins, First Norn, Mezzo soprano Janet Collins, First Norn, Contralto (Female alto) Janet Collins, Flosshilde, Mezzo soprano Lani Poulson, Second Norn, Mezzo soprano Lothar Zagrosek, Conductor Luana DeVol, Brünnhilde, Soprano Richard Wagner, Composer Roland Bracht, Hagen, Bass Sarah Castle, Wellgunde, Soprano Stuttgart State Opera Chorus Stuttgart State Orchestra Sue Patchell, Third Norn, Soprano Tichina Vaughn, Waltraute, Mezzo soprano |
Author: Mike Ashman
Naxos’s first modern Ring cycle ends, as it began, with a thoroughly professional, (almost) unexceptionable performance that served well as the “soundtrack” to Stuttgart’s Millennium production on stage and screen. But there’s little here to counter the feeling of disappointment that Klaus Heymann’s pioneering company have not chosen to make their own Ring from scratch, rather than recycle (albeit cheaply) music-making that many Wagnerians will already own on DVD. And, for the first-time or impulse buyer, there are several more attractive options, starting with the Neuhold Ring (Brilliant Classics) currently available for less than a tenner.
Peter Konwitschny’s staging was the most radical of Stuttgart’s four-separate-productions cycle. His work on text can be heard here in the Norn scene – unusually detailed and intense, especially from Sue Patchell’s Third Norn – and throughout from Albert Bonnema’s Siegfried. The Dutch tenor, a joy to watch onstage, is not, however, a vocalist who always makes for the most mellifluous listening. Some of the off-note singing (and strangulated yelps) he deliberately essays in the hero’s death scene do not come off in audio only. Similarly Bracht’s complex, neurotic Hagen and DeVol’s intentionally OTT Brünnhilde (see the cover picture) seem bland on record. Among what one might call the audio survivors are the Norns and Rhinedaughters, Vaughn’s harried Waltraute and a more multi-faceted than usual Gutrune from Eva-Maria Westbroek.
Lothar Zagrosek’s conducting lies somewhere between a Boulez-like emotional distancing and the swifter, lighter readings of Kempe or Clemens Krauss. His players are alert and sensitive. Recording quality and balance are fine, perhaps smoother than in earlier instalments. Clichés about “if this were the only Götterdämmerung available…” and “of course it’s a good performance standard…” remain resolutely true but it’s hard to recommend this set in the face of so much cheap, more individual competition. Don’t, however, miss the soon-to-be-reissued DVD.
Peter Konwitschny’s staging was the most radical of Stuttgart’s four-separate-productions cycle. His work on text can be heard here in the Norn scene – unusually detailed and intense, especially from Sue Patchell’s Third Norn – and throughout from Albert Bonnema’s Siegfried. The Dutch tenor, a joy to watch onstage, is not, however, a vocalist who always makes for the most mellifluous listening. Some of the off-note singing (and strangulated yelps) he deliberately essays in the hero’s death scene do not come off in audio only. Similarly Bracht’s complex, neurotic Hagen and DeVol’s intentionally OTT Brünnhilde (see the cover picture) seem bland on record. Among what one might call the audio survivors are the Norns and Rhinedaughters, Vaughn’s harried Waltraute and a more multi-faceted than usual Gutrune from Eva-Maria Westbroek.
Lothar Zagrosek’s conducting lies somewhere between a Boulez-like emotional distancing and the swifter, lighter readings of Kempe or Clemens Krauss. His players are alert and sensitive. Recording quality and balance are fine, perhaps smoother than in earlier instalments. Clichés about “if this were the only Götterdämmerung available…” and “of course it’s a good performance standard…” remain resolutely true but it’s hard to recommend this set in the face of so much cheap, more individual competition. Don’t, however, miss the soon-to-be-reissued DVD.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.
Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
SubscribeGramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.