Turnage Scorched
The potent return of the Turnage/Scofield combo giving the music real edge
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Mark-Anthony Turnage
Genre:
Chamber
Label: 20/21
Magazine Review Date: 2/2004
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 64
Mastering:
Stereo
DDD
Catalogue Number: 474 729-2GH

Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Scorched |
Mark-Anthony Turnage, Composer
Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra Hessian Radio Big Band John Patitucci, Bass guitar John Scofield, Electric guitar Mark-Anthony Turnage, Composer Peter Erskine, Drum kit |
Author: David Gutman
Even when writing for the rarefied atmosphere of the concert hall, Mark-Anthony Turnage’s music is strongly coloured by his love affair with jazz. Blood on the Floor (Argo, 5/98) was his first piece to feature improvised sections, and the project enabled him to work with distinguished jazz guitarist John Scofield. This new disc, an edited version of a live event, presents a further collaboration between the two. The punning title alludes to the nature of the work: SCofield ORCHestratED is a dozen of Scofield’s own compositions arranged, ‘set’ or recontextualised by Turnage for the combined forces of the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra, the Hessian Radio Big Band and a dynamic concertante trio of other Turnage collaborators.
The soundworld will be familiar from Turnage’s previous works. There are moments of 1970s cop-show sleaze (perhaps the stylistic homage is intended) but the synthesis of classical and jazz elements is more convincing than in most so-called ‘fusion’, with a real sense of two musicians striking sparks off one another. Turnage gives surprising new perspectives to Scofield’s epigrammatic, angular tunes, which in turn lend the music a focus sometimes missing from the composer’s recent pieces. Gil Evans-ish harmonies acquire Birtwistlian edge even if there’s nothing formidably challenging for the traditional new music audience. The more directly expressive material ranges from the lyrical romanticism of ‘Away With Words’ to the sepulchral chill of ‘Deadzy’ where Turnage begins with some haunting, spaced-out sonorities redolent of Valentin Silvestrov.
There’s a nice balance between Turnage’s carefully crafted structures and the improvised trio elements; the opening number ‘Make Me’ is heard first in Turnage’s pointillist arrangement, then more or less ‘straight’ as a jazz-funk jam of thrilling rhythmic fluidity. The trick doesn’t always work: Turnage’s pizzicato-heavy arrangement of ‘Fat Lip’ sounds effete and aimless next to the sinuous trio version that follows. This is partly due to a lack of swing in the playing, partly a matter of the different miking styles. Scofield’s guitar appears periodically throughout the suite with well-judged contributions, and orchestra and trio are beautifully integrated in up-tempo numbers like ‘Trim’ and ‘Protocol’.
True, there are the usual problems attendant on live recording. Sometimes the ensemble isn’t as tight as it might be, and there are several audible page turns. Intrusive audience applause may annoy some, though it adds to the atmosphere. For the most part, the sound is immediate and vivid. Handsomely packaged and with informative if over-eager booklet notes, this is a successful example of an oft-derided genre.
The soundworld will be familiar from Turnage’s previous works. There are moments of 1970s cop-show sleaze (perhaps the stylistic homage is intended) but the synthesis of classical and jazz elements is more convincing than in most so-called ‘fusion’, with a real sense of two musicians striking sparks off one another. Turnage gives surprising new perspectives to Scofield’s epigrammatic, angular tunes, which in turn lend the music a focus sometimes missing from the composer’s recent pieces. Gil Evans-ish harmonies acquire Birtwistlian edge even if there’s nothing formidably challenging for the traditional new music audience. The more directly expressive material ranges from the lyrical romanticism of ‘Away With Words’ to the sepulchral chill of ‘Deadzy’ where Turnage begins with some haunting, spaced-out sonorities redolent of Valentin Silvestrov.
There’s a nice balance between Turnage’s carefully crafted structures and the improvised trio elements; the opening number ‘Make Me’ is heard first in Turnage’s pointillist arrangement, then more or less ‘straight’ as a jazz-funk jam of thrilling rhythmic fluidity. The trick doesn’t always work: Turnage’s pizzicato-heavy arrangement of ‘Fat Lip’ sounds effete and aimless next to the sinuous trio version that follows. This is partly due to a lack of swing in the playing, partly a matter of the different miking styles. Scofield’s guitar appears periodically throughout the suite with well-judged contributions, and orchestra and trio are beautifully integrated in up-tempo numbers like ‘Trim’ and ‘Protocol’.
True, there are the usual problems attendant on live recording. Sometimes the ensemble isn’t as tight as it might be, and there are several audible page turns. Intrusive audience applause may annoy some, though it adds to the atmosphere. For the most part, the sound is immediate and vivid. Handsomely packaged and with informative if over-eager booklet notes, this is a successful example of an oft-derided genre.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.

Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.