Stravinsky (Le) Rossignol
Using DVD to provide an object lesson in how to make a real film of an opera
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Igor Stravinsky
Genre:
DVD
Label: Virgin
Magazine Review Date: 9/2005
Media Format: Digital Versatile Disc
Media Runtime: 102
Mastering:
Stereo
Catalogue Number: 544242-9
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f3881/f3881b216883404cace41f9d858ae1d8527746d0" alt="Stravinsky's Le rossignol"
Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
(The) Nightingale |
Igor Stravinsky, Composer
Albert Schagidullin, Emperor, Baritone Igor Stravinsky, Composer James Conlon, Conductor Laurent Naouri, Chamberlain, Bass-baritone Marie McLaughlin, Cook, Soprano Maxim Mikhailov, Bonze, Baritone Natalie Dessay, Nightingale, Soprano Paris National Opera Chorus Paris National Opera Orchestra Violeta Urmana, Death, Soprano Vsevolod Grivnov, Fisherman, Tenor |
Author: Mike Ashman
The opera-on-DVD catalogue sells the medium short. Great singing and conducting is a raison d’être for recording, not necessarily for filming; too many mediocre stage productions are being preserved for vocal, not visual, reasons. All the more important, then, is a release like this where a skilled (and musically literate) film director uses state-of-the-art computer technology to sculpt a multi-dimensional portrait of Stravinsky’s gorgeous pre-First World War opera-pantomime.
Christian Chaudet bases it on the EMI recording of 1999 (well received by Michael Oliver, 1/00), reuniting the major soloists in front of blank blue- and green-screens to act their hearts out to imaginary scenery, effects and people that the computer will supply later. This technique, long used in feature films, has a range and flexibility that might have been created for 20th-century opera.
The film begins with a fairly traditional dream frame: a little boy ‘sees’ his father’s pottery turn into a Chinese landscape introducing all the story’s characters and events. Later, the Emperor who so desires the Nightingale’s singing is seen to live in a forbidden city made of chinaware. This image of communication via images coming to life is developed to include the presence of mobile phones (with the Nightingale’s image and song), webcams and computer screens – a modernisation that works through seamless integration with more traditional references. Relevant instruments of the orchestra are also frequently dropped into view as part of the digital landscape.
Wearing a selection of T-shirts that almost suggest a 1960s Bond girl, Natalie Dessay gives a mesmerising but never indulgent or twee performance as the Nightingale, sometimes with a real bird in the hand. Marie McLaughlin’s Cook (who steers the Child through the dream) is equally comfortable and subtle on close-up camera, while Schagidullin, Mikhailov and Naouri exhibit much presence and facial dexterity. From all his players Chaudet has secured that deliberately unemotional and real acting that so distinguishes French (and American) cinema and is such an asset in music-theatre of this genre.
The DVD is of a high visual and sonic quality and (another rarity in opera releases) there are some worthwhile ‘extras’ not devoted to company promotion. These ‘making of’ features really show you something of how the film was technically achieved.
On the soundtrack (as we may now call it) James Conlon goes all out for a colour and bite that binds Stravinsky’s 1908-09 Debussian Act 1 more closely to the 1913-14, post-Rite of Spring final acts than a trenchant, Boulezian approach might have done, although it is not the only way. The singing is first-rate (as was the language-coaching), seeming almost to have been achieved in anticipation of this outstanding film.
Christian Chaudet bases it on the EMI recording of 1999 (well received by Michael Oliver, 1/00), reuniting the major soloists in front of blank blue- and green-screens to act their hearts out to imaginary scenery, effects and people that the computer will supply later. This technique, long used in feature films, has a range and flexibility that might have been created for 20th-century opera.
The film begins with a fairly traditional dream frame: a little boy ‘sees’ his father’s pottery turn into a Chinese landscape introducing all the story’s characters and events. Later, the Emperor who so desires the Nightingale’s singing is seen to live in a forbidden city made of chinaware. This image of communication via images coming to life is developed to include the presence of mobile phones (with the Nightingale’s image and song), webcams and computer screens – a modernisation that works through seamless integration with more traditional references. Relevant instruments of the orchestra are also frequently dropped into view as part of the digital landscape.
Wearing a selection of T-shirts that almost suggest a 1960s Bond girl, Natalie Dessay gives a mesmerising but never indulgent or twee performance as the Nightingale, sometimes with a real bird in the hand. Marie McLaughlin’s Cook (who steers the Child through the dream) is equally comfortable and subtle on close-up camera, while Schagidullin, Mikhailov and Naouri exhibit much presence and facial dexterity. From all his players Chaudet has secured that deliberately unemotional and real acting that so distinguishes French (and American) cinema and is such an asset in music-theatre of this genre.
The DVD is of a high visual and sonic quality and (another rarity in opera releases) there are some worthwhile ‘extras’ not devoted to company promotion. These ‘making of’ features really show you something of how the film was technically achieved.
On the soundtrack (as we may now call it) James Conlon goes all out for a colour and bite that binds Stravinsky’s 1908-09 Debussian Act 1 more closely to the 1913-14, post-Rite of Spring final acts than a trenchant, Boulezian approach might have done, although it is not the only way. The singing is first-rate (as was the language-coaching), seeming almost to have been achieved in anticipation of this outstanding film.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d6841/d6841d4c183e0e3d3010c3ed9ec2687496170b61" alt=""
Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribedata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/895a7/895a760c19a9a07d423de6e8fb38a699c627c062" alt=""
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.