Schumann; Dvorak Piano Concertos

Two very fine accounts of the Dvor¨¢k Concerto but which is the one to buy?

Record and Artist Details

Composer or Director: Antonín Dvořák

Genre:

Orchestral

Label: Bridge

Media Format: CD or Download

Media Runtime: 0

Mastering:

Stereo
DDD

Catalogue Number: BRIDGE9309

Tracks:

Composition Artist Credit
Concerto for Piano and Orchestra Antonín Dvořák, Composer
Antonín Dvořák, Composer
Justin Brown, Conductor
Odense Symphony Orchestra
Vassily Primakov, Piano
Poetic tone pictures, Movement: Nocturnal route Antonín Dvořák, Composer
Antonín Dvořák, Composer
Vassily Primakov, Piano
Poetic tone pictures, Movement: At the old castle Antonín Dvořák, Composer
Antonín Dvořák, Composer
Vassily Primakov, Piano
Poetic tone pictures, Movement: Reverie Antonín Dvořák, Composer
Antonín Dvořák, Composer
Vassily Primakov, Piano
Poetic tone pictures, Movement: Goblins' dance Antonín Dvořák, Composer
Antonín Dvořák, Composer
Vassily Primakov, Piano
Poetic tone pictures, Movement: By the tumulus Antonín Dvořák, Composer
Antonín Dvořák, Composer
Vassily Primakov, Piano

Label: Pentatone

Media Format: Super Audio CD

Media Runtime: 0

Mastering:

Stereo

Catalogue Number: PTC5186333

Dvorák’s Piano Concerto is a problematic work. Even Sviatoslav Richter admitted that it remained among his greatest challenges, referring to many opaque and unpianistic demands that take their lead from the Brahms concertos. Attempts to make the solo part more grateful and accessible by Vilem Kurtz, Firkusny and Reizenstein hardly improved matters and it is surely significant that Primakov and Helmchen, the Concerto’s newest recorded champions, have returned to the original score.

Both pianists are clearly in love with music that releases its secrets slowly, the truth lying somewhere between Primakov’s delicacy and brilliance and Helmchen’s greater introspection. Both achieve their goal in making even the most workaday passages somehow take wing. And elsewhere their warmth is almost palpable in, for example, the finale’s second subject contrast to the prevailing folk-dance element or in the central Andante’s Chopinesque tracery. Echoes of Beethoven, Brahms and (amusingly) Liszt’s Grand Chromatic Galop at the close of the Andante are resolved where Dvorák struggles to find an identity which achieved its fullest glory in the later Cello Concerto.

Choice between these two recordings will perhaps depend on their couplings, a perhaps overly respectable way with the Schumann Piano Concerto from Helmchen and a magical and scintillating realisation of Dvorák’s Poetic Tone-Pictures by Primakov. Both pianists are finely partnered and recorded, but personally I would go for Primakov, not forgetting Richter’s own superb performance on EMI’s Great Recordings of the Century label (9/77R).

Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music. 

Stream on Presto Music | Buy from Presto Music

Gramophone Print

  • Print Edition

From £6.67 / month

Subscribe

Gramophone Digital Club

  • Digital Edition
  • Digital Archive
  • Reviews Database
  • Full website access

From £8.75 / month

Subscribe

                              

If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.