Reginald Mobley: Because
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Baptiste Trotignon
Genre:
Vocal
Label: Alpha
Magazine Review Date: 08/2023
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 55
Mastering:
DDD
Catalogue Number: ALPHA936
Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Sometimes I feel like a motherless child |
Anonymous, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
Were you there? |
Traditional, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
I got a robe |
Traditional, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
Why |
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
Because |
Florence Bea(trice) Price, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
Steal Away |
Traditional, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
Save Me Lord, Save Me |
Traditional, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
Bright Sparkles in the Churchyard |
Traditional, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
Nobody knows the trouble I seen |
Traditional, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
Resignation |
Florence Bea(trice) Price, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
A Great Campmeetin' |
Anonymous, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
Sunset |
Florence Bea(trice) Price, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
My Lord, what a morning |
Traditional, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
Jean |
Henry Thacker Burleigh, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
There is a balm in Gilead |
Traditional, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
I Heard It Through the Grapevine |
Barrett Strong, Composer
Norman Whitfield, Composer Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
Deep River |
Traditional, Composer
Baptiste Trotignon, Composer Reginald Mobley, Countertenor |
Author: Jeremy Nicholas
‘“Because” reflects our wish to give this powerful repertoire [of African American songs] a new interpretation,’ write the two artists, ‘to offer it a different sound from the one it is more used to.’ A further difference is to eschew ‘the “classical” textual approach to these songs, while still not at all genuinely “jazz” in flavour’. To summarise, it’s a cross between ‘love and respect for the heritage of the genre and a freedom to improvise, as if potentially reinventing the present moment’.
All very intriguing and worthy. But the CD gets off to a disconcerting start for three reasons: one, no listener will be prepared for the sound of a classically trained countertenor singing Spirituals; two, the countertenor voice is one associated predominantly, but not exclusively, with music of the Baroque era, with its precise metre and phrasing; three, while a distinctive jazz piano arrangement of such material makes an interesting alternative to the norm (the classic and much-loved settings by Harry Burleigh, say, or Sydney Baynes), such a setting must surely be sensitive to the words. Which is why a hard-driven agitato piano beneath the heart-wrenching melody of ‘Sometimes I feel like a motherless child’ simply does not work – especially as an opener.
Better to have begun with the exuberant ‘I got a robe’, where the accompaniment by pianist Baptiste Trotignon (10 of the 18 numbers here are arranged by him) perfectly complements the text. Or with the track that precedes it, the Crucifixion song ‘Were you there?’, the first part sung a cappella with immense grace by the mellifluous American Reginald Mobley. Close your eyes, it might be Marian Anderson. Two tracks on and we come to ‘Steal away’, which is, for me, the highlight of the disc and where text, melody, arrangement, voice and piano all combine for a few minutes of heart-stopping beauty. Likewise ‘Deep river’, the final track, is most touchingly done by both artists.
Before that, in addition to further Spirituals, there is the title-track ‘Because’ – not the famous old ballad by Guy d’Hardelot but a song by the now-ubiquitous Florence Price. She, with the aforementioned Harry Burleigh, provides three more saccharine ditties. There is also an ill-advised rendition of the Motown classic ‘I heard it through the grapevine’, which falls some way short of Marvin Gaye’s imperishable original. Good booklet in French, English and German with, unusually, all the song lyrics in English and French.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.

Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.