Nielsen Flute Concerto; Symphony No 5
An accomplished Nielsen triptych, but Elder’s Fifth fails to storm the heavens
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Carl Nielsen
Genre:
Orchestral
Label: Hallé
Magazine Review Date: 7/2003
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 60
Mastering:
Stereo
DDD
Catalogue Number: CDHLL7502
Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Symphony No. 5 |
Carl Nielsen, Composer
Carl Nielsen, Composer Hallé Orchestra Mark Elder, Conductor |
Concerto for Flute and Orchestra |
Carl Nielsen, Composer
Andrew Nicholson, Flute Carl Nielsen, Composer Hallé Orchestra Mark Elder, Conductor |
Aladdin, Movement: Entrance March |
Carl Nielsen, Composer
Carl Nielsen, Composer Hallé Orchestra Mark Elder, Conductor |
Author: Andrew Achenbach
Bouquets first. The Hallé’s principal flute, Andrew Nicholson, makes an immaculate showing in Nielsen’s engagingly bitter-sweet Concerto and he’s backed to the hilt by his admirably spick-and-span colleagues under Mark Elder’s watchful lead. Theirs is a performance of strong character and palpable dedication, if ultimately a little lacking in smiling spontaneity and without quite the entrancing grace and sheer poetry of the Gallois/Chung account, not to mention dedicatee Holger Gilbert-Jespersen’s pioneering 1954 version with Thomas Jensen. It’s followed by a stylish first recording of the discarded ‘Entrance March’ from Nielsen’s extensive 1919 incidental music for Aladdin (the composer wisely replaced it with the far more memorable ‘Oriental Festive March’ instead).
As for the mighty Fifth Symphony, well, Elder’s reading has much in its favour. Patient tempi go hand in hand with an intelligent sense of proportion and extraordinary, albeit occasionally fussy, attention to detail (Nielsen’s daringly confrontational writing for flute, clarinet and percussion is, however, captured with tremendous clarity). At the same time, I’d have welcomed a greater sense of purpose and momentum: tensions dissipate as Elder gently applies the brakes for those two tranquillo markings at fig 16 (6'45") and two before 24 (9'59") in the opening Tempo giusto, while the towering second movement ‘stacks up’ to far more convincing effect in Bostock’s lively and personable RLPO account (where the orchestral playing is marginally less tidy but rather more communicative than here). Worth sampling, certainly, but there’s something just a touch calculated about the finished article; to my ears, Elder’s Nielsen 5 never truly catches fire. With the exception of the disappointingly low-key Schønwandt, you can, I think, do better with any of the comparative contenders listed above.
As for the mighty Fifth Symphony, well, Elder’s reading has much in its favour. Patient tempi go hand in hand with an intelligent sense of proportion and extraordinary, albeit occasionally fussy, attention to detail (Nielsen’s daringly confrontational writing for flute, clarinet and percussion is, however, captured with tremendous clarity). At the same time, I’d have welcomed a greater sense of purpose and momentum: tensions dissipate as Elder gently applies the brakes for those two tranquillo markings at fig 16 (6'45") and two before 24 (9'59") in the opening Tempo giusto, while the towering second movement ‘stacks up’ to far more convincing effect in Bostock’s lively and personable RLPO account (where the orchestral playing is marginally less tidy but rather more communicative than here). Worth sampling, certainly, but there’s something just a touch calculated about the finished article; to my ears, Elder’s Nielsen 5 never truly catches fire. With the exception of the disappointingly low-key Schønwandt, you can, I think, do better with any of the comparative contenders listed above.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.
Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
SubscribeGramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.