Mahler Symphony No 2; Mozart Symphony No 29
It’s Klemperer and Mahler 2, but do we really need it?
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Gustav Mahler, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
Genre:
Orchestral
Label: Testament
Magazine Review Date: 5/2005
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 108
Mastering:
Stereo
ADD
Catalogue Number: SBT21348

Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Symphony No. 29 |
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Composer
Otto Klemperer, Conductor Philharmonia Orchestra Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Composer |
Symphony No. 2, 'Resurrection' |
Gustav Mahler, Composer
Gustav Mahler, Composer Heather Harper, Soprano Janet Baker, Mezzo soprano Otto Klemperer, Conductor Philharmonia Chorus Philharmonia Orchestra |
Author: David Gutman
Expertly transferred by Paul Baily and with detailed notes by Mike Ashman, this is a release to evoke a bygone era. Whether the actual music-making will inspire the under-50sI am less sure. In the 1920s Klemperer’s adamantine conducting style was thought the height of modernity and he himself was moved to find echoes of it at the very end of his life in the attitude of Pierre Boulez. That said, without the unanimity and clear-cut, wind-dominated textures achieved in his best studio recordings, the objective approach risks falling flat even in what would never then have been called signature works. His earlier (mono) LP of the Mozart, one of the first he made with the Philharmonia for EMI, is available on Testament. En route to a looser stereo remake, this live performance begins with a rugged and characteristically moderate Allegro moderato, the remaining movements being more in line with Sixties expectations.
The Mahler should matter more. As one of the composer’s original disciples, Klemperer’s devotion was unquestionable if not unquestioning in the manner we take for granted today. Of the symphonies he actually conducted, the Second was a regular calling card. In addition to the studio versions for Vox and, famously, EMI, the ardent fan can seek out live performances given in Amsterdam with Ferrier, in Sydney, Vienna, Munich and again in London. Of these, the 1965 Bavarian Radio relay is perhaps the finest, Janet Baker and Heather Harper repeating their sterling contributions to the present Royal Festival Hall concert. If you weren’t at the RFH in 1963 and already have that Munich account on EMI’s single disc, only the more natural microphone placing for Dame Janet and Testament’s wider dynamic range might conceivably justify the duplication involved.
Alas, the London ‘Urlicht’ offers the soloist little in the way of affectionate space or even rhythmic security. It’s the finale that best conveys the authentic gravitas and cumulative intensity of the ‘transfigured Kapellmeister’. The opening movement, always surprisingly brisk and generalised with him, has to work to find the intended physicality: the lacklustre start is presumably attributable to that famously incomprehensible beat. In the manner of the Naxos Toscanini broadcasts applause is retained before and after each work, although we are spared the Third Programme commentary.
It is as well to be reminded just how much an outsider Mahler remained at this time with Neville Cardus his only ardent champion among the UK’s newspaper critics. So is this a period piece or something more? As with some of Testament’s recent Barbirolli revivifications, I have my doubts.
The Mahler should matter more. As one of the composer’s original disciples, Klemperer’s devotion was unquestionable if not unquestioning in the manner we take for granted today. Of the symphonies he actually conducted, the Second was a regular calling card. In addition to the studio versions for Vox and, famously, EMI, the ardent fan can seek out live performances given in Amsterdam with Ferrier, in Sydney, Vienna, Munich and again in London. Of these, the 1965 Bavarian Radio relay is perhaps the finest, Janet Baker and Heather Harper repeating their sterling contributions to the present Royal Festival Hall concert. If you weren’t at the RFH in 1963 and already have that Munich account on EMI’s single disc, only the more natural microphone placing for Dame Janet and Testament’s wider dynamic range might conceivably justify the duplication involved.
Alas, the London ‘Urlicht’ offers the soloist little in the way of affectionate space or even rhythmic security. It’s the finale that best conveys the authentic gravitas and cumulative intensity of the ‘transfigured Kapellmeister’. The opening movement, always surprisingly brisk and generalised with him, has to work to find the intended physicality: the lacklustre start is presumably attributable to that famously incomprehensible beat. In the manner of the Naxos Toscanini broadcasts applause is retained before and after each work, although we are spared the Third Programme commentary.
It is as well to be reminded just how much an outsider Mahler remained at this time with Neville Cardus his only ardent champion among the UK’s newspaper critics. So is this a period piece or something more? As with some of Testament’s recent Barbirolli revivifications, I have my doubts.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.

Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.