Ligeti - Clear or Cloudy
A bargain set marking Ligeti’s death makes a fine survey of his output
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: György Ligeti
Genre:
Orchestral
Label: Deutsche Grammophon
Magazine Review Date: 12/2006
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 0
Mastering:
Stereo
DDD
Catalogue Number: 477 6443-GH4

Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Sonata for Cello |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer Matt Haimovitz, Cello |
(6) Bagatelles |
György Ligeti, Composer
Douglas Boyd, Oboe György Ligeti, Composer Jacques Zoon, Flute James Sommerville, Horn Matthew Wilkie, Bassoon Richard Hosford, Clarinet |
String Quartet No. 1, 'Métamorphoses nocturnes' |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer Hagen Quartet |
(10) Pieces |
György Ligeti, Composer
Fritz Faltl, Bassoon Gerhard Turetschek, Oboe György Ligeti, Composer Peter Schmidl, Clarinet Volker Altmann, Horn Wolfgang Schulz, Flute |
String Quartet No. 2 |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer LaSalle Quartet |
Atmosphères |
György Ligeti, Composer
Claudio Abbado, Conductor György Ligeti, Composer Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra |
Volumina |
György Ligeti, Composer
Gerd Zacher, Organ György Ligeti, Composer |
Lux aeterna |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer Helmut Franz, Conductor North German Radio Chorus |
Organ Study No. 1, 'Harmonies' |
György Ligeti, Composer
Gerd Zacher, Organ György Ligeti, Composer |
Lontano |
György Ligeti, Composer
Claudio Abbado, Conductor György Ligeti, Composer Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra |
Ramifications |
György Ligeti, Composer
Ensemble InterContemporain, Paris György Ligeti, Composer Pierre Boulez, Conductor |
Melodien |
György Ligeti, Composer
David Atherton, Conductor György Ligeti, Composer London Sinfonietta |
Aventures |
György Ligeti, Composer
Ensemble InterContemporain, Paris György Ligeti, Composer Jane Manning, Soprano Mary Thomas, Soprano Pierre Boulez, Conductor William Pearson, Baritone |
Nouvelles Aventures |
György Ligeti, Composer
Ensemble InterContemporain, Paris György Ligeti, Composer Jane Manning, Soprano Mary Thomas, Soprano Pierre Boulez, Conductor William Pearson, Baritone |
Concerto for Cello and Orchestra |
György Ligeti, Composer
Ensemble InterContemporain, Paris György Ligeti, Composer Jean-Guihen Queyras, Cello Pierre Boulez, Conductor |
Chamber Concerto |
György Ligeti, Composer
Ensemble InterContemporain, Paris György Ligeti, Composer Pierre Boulez, Conductor |
Mysteries of the Macabre |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer Håkan Hardenberger, Trumpet Roland Pöntinen, Piano |
Concerto for Flute, Oboe and Strings |
György Ligeti, Composer
Chamber Orchestra of Europe Claudio Abbado, Conductor Douglas Boyd, Oboe György Ligeti, Composer Jacques Zoon, Flute |
(Die) grosse Schildkröten-Fanfare vom Südchinesischen Meer |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer Håkan Hardenberger, Trumpet |
(3) Pieces |
György Ligeti, Composer
Alfons Kontarsky, Piano Aloys Kontarsky, Piano György Ligeti, Composer |
Etudes, Book 1, Movement: Cordes à vide |
György Ligeti, Composer
Gianluca Cascioli, Piano György Ligeti, Composer |
Etudes, Book 1, Movement: Fanfares |
György Ligeti, Composer
Gianluca Cascioli, Piano György Ligeti, Composer |
Concerto for Piano and Orchestra |
György Ligeti, Composer
Ensemble InterContemporain, Paris Ensemble InterContemporain, Paris György Ligeti, Composer Pierre Boulez, Conductor Pierre-Laurent Aimard, Piano |
Concerto for Violin and Orchestra |
György Ligeti, Composer
Ensemble InterContemporain, Paris Ensemble InterContemporain, Paris György Ligeti, Composer Pierre Boulez, Conductor Saschko Gawriloff, Violin |
Author: Peter Quantrill
So DG is the first record company to honour/cash in on the death of Ligeti in June. Actually I hope they do cash in, because anyone still wondering what all the fuss is about could do no better than start here. The chronological ordering of each disc reveals not differing preoccupations but growing mastery in realising their potential: from the internalised dialogue of the Cello Sonata (1948-53) to the self-defining, dramatic genius of the Second Quartet (1968); from everyone’s big discovery of the Ligeti Sound in Atmosphères (1961) to its self-assured apex in Melodien (1971).
Most of the DG recordings were made in the 1980s and early 1990s, and represent a Second Wave of Ligeti recordings. They lack on one hand the buzz (acoustic and musical) of Wergo’s pioneering work, and on the other the composer’s imprimatur on the complete edition shared between Sony and Warner. Clear or cloudy? Definitely clear. What else would you expect with Pierre Boulez in charge? He leaves extroversion to the singers in Aventures/Nouvelles Aventures, but I hear more of the notes than on any of the other four versions I know. Ligeti didn’t shun old-fashioned virtuosity, he revelled in it, and so do Pierre-Laurent Aimard and Saschko Gawriloff in the late concertos for piano and violin. However, my own picks from this set date from when the music was wet on the page. The LaSalle Quartet don’t treat the Second Quartet as a monolith of 20th-century quartet-writing; listening to them there is no sense of the compilation aesthetic that others have found in the piece. The frankly scary sounds that Gerd Zacher gets from an organ in Volumina surpass even his own Vox recording from the same period (1968). And the Kontarsky piano duo are irresistible in the Three Pieces, the triptych Ligeti wrote with them in mind. The second panel is a “Self portrait with Reich and Riley (and Chopin’s there somewhere)”. Hardly since Beethoven has music been able to laugh at itself and be worthy of the joke. I’d like to think that the three of them are now enjoying it together.
Most of the DG recordings were made in the 1980s and early 1990s, and represent a Second Wave of Ligeti recordings. They lack on one hand the buzz (acoustic and musical) of Wergo’s pioneering work, and on the other the composer’s imprimatur on the complete edition shared between Sony and Warner. Clear or cloudy? Definitely clear. What else would you expect with Pierre Boulez in charge? He leaves extroversion to the singers in Aventures/Nouvelles Aventures, but I hear more of the notes than on any of the other four versions I know. Ligeti didn’t shun old-fashioned virtuosity, he revelled in it, and so do Pierre-Laurent Aimard and Saschko Gawriloff in the late concertos for piano and violin. However, my own picks from this set date from when the music was wet on the page. The LaSalle Quartet don’t treat the Second Quartet as a monolith of 20th-century quartet-writing; listening to them there is no sense of the compilation aesthetic that others have found in the piece. The frankly scary sounds that Gerd Zacher gets from an organ in Volumina surpass even his own Vox recording from the same period (1968). And the Kontarsky piano duo are irresistible in the Three Pieces, the triptych Ligeti wrote with them in mind. The second panel is a “Self portrait with Reich and Riley (and Chopin’s there somewhere)”. Hardly since Beethoven has music been able to laugh at itself and be worthy of the joke. I’d like to think that the three of them are now enjoying it together.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.

Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.