JOUBERT South of the Line
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Paul Spicer
Genre:
Vocal
Label: Somm Recordings
Magazine Review Date: 05/2017
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 80
Mastering:
DDD
Catalogue Number: SOMMCD0166
Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Autumn Rain |
John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer
Birmingham Conservatoire Chamber Choir Domonkos Csabay, Piano John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer Paul Spicer, Composer |
Be not afeard |
John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer
Birmingham Conservatoire Chamber Choir John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer Paul Spicer, Composer |
Incantation |
John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer
Birmingham Conservatoire Chamber Choir John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer Paul Spicer, Composer |
O Lorde, the maker of al thing |
John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer
Birmingham Conservatoire Chamber Choir John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer Nicholas Wearne, Organ Paul Spicer, Composer |
O Praise God In His Holiness |
John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer
Birmingham Conservatoire Chamber Choir John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer Nicholas Wearne, Organ Paul Spicer, Composer |
Pilgrimage Song |
John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer
Birmingham Conservatoire Chamber Choir John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer Paul Spicer, Composer |
Sonnet |
John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer
Birmingham Conservatoire Chamber Choir John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer Paul Spicer, Composer |
South of the Line |
John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer
Birmingham Conservatoire Chamber Choir Domonkos Csabay, Piano George Kirkham, Percussion György Hodzso, Piano Harry Bent, Percussion John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer Matthew Firkins, Timpani Miriam Kitchener, Percussion Paul Spicer, Composer Stephen Plummer, Percussion |
There is no Rose |
John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer
Birmingham Conservatoire Chamber Choir John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer Paul Spicer, Composer |
This is the Gate of the Lord |
John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer
Birmingham Conservatoire Chamber Choir John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer Paul Spicer, Composer |
Three Portraits |
John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer
Birmingham Conservatoire Chamber Choir John (Pierre Herman) Joubert, Composer Paul Spicer, Composer |
Author: Andrew Mellor
Often that directness is founded on a rhythmic impetus, as in O praise God in his holiness and much of South of the Line, the headline work here. Sometimes rhythm is just as important but rendered almost invisible by top-line melodic charm (as in the famous There is no rose and Autumn Rain). Always, text is the starting point. While some works have a Leighton-like underlying savagery that can bubble up via layering or counterpoint (as in Pilgrimage Song and some parts of Incantation), more recent works such as Be not afeard from 2015 suggest that Joubert has softened at the edges.
South of the Line, after Thomas Hardy’s Boer War poetry, can drift into the glib when a distinctly English choral language meets militaristic percussion. But the writing is always full of rigour and, despite the obvious influence of Britten, it could never be parodied. Joubert almost always has a crafty solution in the final bar of a work or movement.
In terms of sound, the confident BCCC are halfway between an undergraduate chapel choir and a conservatoire chamber choir made up of vocal studies students (which they are). The recording could have been better: it renders tenors and basses fuzzy and indistinct (bass tuning can slip and slide, as in the second of the Three Portraits) and instead homes in on the very able soprano group; but they can experience ‘vibrato disagreement’ and curdle at higher volumes and registers.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.
Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
SubscribeGramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.