Horowitz - Complete Original Jacket Collection
A beautifully produced collection that is a fine tribute to a legend
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Label: Sony Classical
Magazine Review Date: 2/2010
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 0
Mastering:
Stereo
Catalogue Number: 88697 57500-2
Author: Jeremy Nicholas
The “Original Jacket Collection” is a joint venture between Sony and RCA. The 70 CDs contain most of Horowitz’s American recordings issued on the RCA, Columbia, CBS and Sony labels between 1928 and 1989 (so no HMV or Deutsche Grammophon). Each disc is a facsimile of the original LP packaging including sleeve-notes (in microscopic typeface) but not the essays that came with LP box sets. My initial reaction was of open-jawed amazement – all these old friends from my teenage years and beyond in miniaturised form. I don’t think I have ever seen a more beautifully produced and stunningly designed set of recordings. On closer inspection, however, all is not quite what it seems – and there are aspects of the project that could have been done better.
Space precludes an appraisal of the performances on all 70 discs. These have, in any case, been well covered in these pages over the years. I suggest a visit to the Gramophone archive (www.gramophone.net). Horowitz collectors will have most of these recordings, with their more than 440 separate titles, but not the two complete recitals given on March 5, 1951, and November 12, 1967. These are previously unreleased (except for two short works from each concert) and include a Prokofiev Sonata No 7 and Chopin’s Polonaise in C sharp minor, Op 26 No 1. The 1976 “Concert of the Century” celebrating the 85th anniversary of Carnegie Hall with Bernstein, Rostropovich, Fischer-Dieskau et al is here, as well as “The Young Horowitz” LP back in the catalogue with the earliest American recordings and Kabalevsky’s Sonata No 3. Omitted are the recently published recordings of Schumann’s Fantaisie (1946), Balakirev’s Islamey and Liszt’s St Francis Walking on the Water (both revised by Horowitz and new to his discography), and other still-unreleased performances such as the Kreisler-Rachmaninov Liebesleid.
Inevitably, there is much duplication of repertoire, reflecting Horowitz’s own musical preference over the years – two Mussorgsky Pictures, the two Tchaikovsky Firsts with Toscanini, two Rach Threes (the glorious 1951 version with Reiner and the unfortunate 1978 travesty with Ormandy), four Kinderszenens and, an extreme example, Debussy’s Serenade for the Doll, which appears six times. The historic 1965 “Carnegie Hall Return Concert” appears on CDs 42a/b and 57a/b, one version edited for clinkers, the other not. Buyers should be aware that these are not 70 CDs with 70- or even 60-plus minutes of music, inevitable if the producers were to preserve the integrity of the original LP format. Six discs have less than 30 minutes of music on them, sixty of them less than 50 minutes. The transfers appear to be the same as those previously released on CD.
The presentation is a disappointment. Try as I might I cannot work out the criterion for how the collection has been ordered – and the classy-looking (CD size) 200-page hardback booklet doesn’t help. 145 pages are taken up with track listings (left hand page) and, quite redundantly, each album cover in black-and-white (right hand page). These are followed by a brisk and sometimes contentious canter through Horowitz’s recorded legacy written by reissue producer Jon M Samuels. There is no chronological list of recordings, nor any means of looking up a composer or piece of music to see which work Horowitz recorded when. An appendix with appropriate CD numbers would have been a simple and beneficial addition. Recording details for CD 2 are missing and a number of typos could have been eliminated with closer proof-reading.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.
Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
SubscribeGramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.