Hindemith; Schumann Cello Concerto
The French cellist’s personality is stamped on every bar of these live performances
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Paul Hindemith, Robert Schumann
Genre:
Orchestral
Label: BBC Music Legends/IMG Artists
Magazine Review Date: 4/2004
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 63
Mastering:
Stereo
DDD
Catalogue Number: BBCL4133-2

Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Concerto for Cello and Orchestra |
Paul Hindemith, Composer
Edward Downes, Conductor New Philharmonia Orchestra Paul Hindemith, Composer Paul Tortelier, Cello |
Author: DuncanDruce
As he makes his first entry after the opening chords of the Schumann, one is immediately drawn into the exciting atmosphere that surrounded Tortelier’s concert appear- ances – this is playing that demands attention. Part of his secret is that he lives the music with such intensity – the flourishes that punctuate Schumann’s opening melody have an amazing, extravagant quality that’s the more striking because they take us by surprise, after the tranquillity of the first bars.
As a recording, this Schumann can’t compare with the late 1970s account where Tortelier is accompanied by the RPO under his son’s baton. It’s a live broadcast, with some audible coughing, the sound is rather glassy, and though there’s the sense of a big orchestra much of the detail is not entirely clear. Nevertheless, the BBC SO plays well and, in front of an audience, Tortelier app- roaches the solo part with more intensity, digging into the obsessive rhythm at the start of the finale, and later on sounding more joyful in his dialogue with the woodwind. In the slow movement, there’s a greater contrast between the more rhetorical passages and exquisitely tender quiet phrases.
The Hindemith was one of Tortelier’s favourite concertos – there’s a splendid 1955 recording with An?erl and the Czech Phil. This 1967 account has better sound than the Schumann, with bright, harmonious wind playing in the Scherzo episode of the middle movement, and in the final March. Tortelier’s bold, sinewy playing seems just right, but he doesn’t quite convince me of the work’s high stature, not even when, on the final track, he talks about it with great charm and enthusiasm.
As a recording, this Schumann can’t compare with the late 1970s account where Tortelier is accompanied by the RPO under his son’s baton. It’s a live broadcast, with some audible coughing, the sound is rather glassy, and though there’s the sense of a big orchestra much of the detail is not entirely clear. Nevertheless, the BBC SO plays well and, in front of an audience, Tortelier app- roaches the solo part with more intensity, digging into the obsessive rhythm at the start of the finale, and later on sounding more joyful in his dialogue with the woodwind. In the slow movement, there’s a greater contrast between the more rhetorical passages and exquisitely tender quiet phrases.
The Hindemith was one of Tortelier’s favourite concertos – there’s a splendid 1955 recording with An?erl and the Czech Phil. This 1967 account has better sound than the Schumann, with bright, harmonious wind playing in the Scherzo episode of the middle movement, and in the final March. Tortelier’s bold, sinewy playing seems just right, but he doesn’t quite convince me of the work’s high stature, not even when, on the final track, he talks about it with great charm and enthusiasm.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.

Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.