Chopin; Liszt; Scriabin Piano Sonatas
More Luisada than Liszt
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Alexander Scriabin, Franz Liszt, Fryderyk Chopin
Genre:
Instrumental
Label: Red Seal
Magazine Review Date: 3/2005
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 78
Mastering:
Stereo
DDD
Catalogue Number: 82876 64561-2

Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Sonata for Piano No. 3 |
Fryderyk Chopin, Composer
Fryderyk Chopin, Composer Jean-Marc Luisada, Piano |
Sonata for Piano |
Franz Liszt, Composer
Franz Liszt, Composer Jean-Marc Luisada, Piano |
Sonata for Piano No. 9, 'Black Mass' |
Alexander Scriabin, Composer
Alexander Scriabin, Composer Jean-Marc Luisada, Piano |
(27) Etudes, Movement: E, Op. 10/3 |
Fryderyk Chopin, Composer
Fryderyk Chopin, Composer Jean-Marc Luisada, Piano |
Author: Bryce Morrison
This imaginatively planned recital couples two cornerstones of the repertoire with Scriabin’s decadent erosion of Romanticism and an encore: Chopin’s surpassingly beautiful Op 10 No 3 Etude. Further interest is supplied by Jean-Marc Luisada’s use of novel editions of both the Liszt and Chopin sonatas (the former from an autograph manuscript found in New York, the latter – and also the Etude – from Henle). These give us many intriguing alternatives to convention even when they hardly add conviction to Luisada’s performances.
For some, his playing will suggest a personal crusade and adventure; others will view his readings as shamelessly indulgent. The catalogue is filled to bursting with great recordings of these romantic masterpieces, making it doubly hard to accept playing where the heavy hand of the ‘interpreter’ bears down on virtually every bar. Chopin’s Allegro maestoso opening to his B minor Sonata collapses under the strain of extravagant stop-go rubato, and why start the Largo’s central sostenuto quaver flow at a radically faster, unmarked tempo? Even the great, equestrian finale is subject to distortion.
The Liszt Sonata presents the same sorry tale, with the principal theme weakly presented and disfiguring changes of tempo, dictated, I suspect, more from technical limitations than musical conviction. Scriabin’s Black Mass Sonata and the Chopin Etude, too, come close to parody. All these performances are recorded in a close and airless acoustic.
For some, his playing will suggest a personal crusade and adventure; others will view his readings as shamelessly indulgent. The catalogue is filled to bursting with great recordings of these romantic masterpieces, making it doubly hard to accept playing where the heavy hand of the ‘interpreter’ bears down on virtually every bar. Chopin’s Allegro maestoso opening to his B minor Sonata collapses under the strain of extravagant stop-go rubato, and why start the Largo’s central sostenuto quaver flow at a radically faster, unmarked tempo? Even the great, equestrian finale is subject to distortion.
The Liszt Sonata presents the same sorry tale, with the principal theme weakly presented and disfiguring changes of tempo, dictated, I suspect, more from technical limitations than musical conviction. Scriabin’s Black Mass Sonata and the Chopin Etude, too, come close to parody. All these performances are recorded in a close and airless acoustic.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.

Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.