Bloch Violin Sonatas
A superb partnership shine on a superb recording
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Ernest Bloch
Genre:
Chamber
Label: Hyperion
Magazine Review Date: 4/2005
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 69
Mastering:
Stereo
DDD
Catalogue Number: CDA67439

Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Sonata for Violin and Piano No. 1 |
Ernest Bloch, Composer
Arnon Erez, Piano Ernest Bloch, Composer Hagai Shaham, Violin |
Sonata for Violin and Piano No. 2, 'Poème mystiq |
Ernest Bloch, Composer
Arnon Erez, Piano Ernest Bloch, Composer Hagai Shaham, Violin |
Melody |
Ernest Bloch, Composer
Arnon Erez, Piano Ernest Bloch, Composer Hagai Shaham, Violin |
Nuit exotique |
Ernest Bloch, Composer
Arnon Erez, Piano Ernest Bloch, Composer Hagai Shaham, Violin |
Abodah |
Ernest Bloch, Composer
Arnon Erez, Piano Ernest Bloch, Composer Hagai Shaham, Violin |
Author: Rob Cowan
There are significant parallels between the violin sonatas of Bloch and Bartók, not least their uncompromising musical language. All four works date from the early 1920s, Bloch’s First preceding Bartók’s by a year, whereas his Second Sonata was composed some two years after Bartók’s Second. My guess is there was some sort of reciprocal influence at play: indeed we know (from Alexander Knapp’s excellent notes) that Bartók performed Bloch’s First Sonata in recital and the angular, aggressive language of its outer movements has a very Bartókian thrust.
The symbiotic musical partnership of Hagai Shaham and Arnon Erez take that aggression as a starting point, but they also achieve a more inward communion for the work’s central Molto quieto. The Second Sonata follows Bartók’s Second in trading outward aggression for inward agitation and an earthy spirituality, folk-like in Bartók’s case (whose slow-fast pattern recalls Liszt’s and Bartók’s own Hungarian Rhapsodies), with Bloch more attuned to the world of prayer.
Bloch saw his Second Sonata as a fervid, idealistic counterbalance to the primordial onrush of his First, and the ecstatic harmonies that dominate the Second Sonata’s solo line have a profoundly prayerful effect. Shaham again scales the heights with mostly true intonation, a warm tone and meaty double-stops, though as soon as the first notes have sounded the searing benchmark of Jascha Heifetz inevitably invades the memory, more so than in the First Sonata, where the tender-hearted Louis Kaufman merits a special mention. That said, in both sonatas Shaham enjoys a more equal partnership with his pianists than Heifetz did.
The makeweights for this particular programme work well in context, Nuit exotique having a more eastern feel than the relatively modest Mélodie. Abodah (‘God’s Worship’), written for the child Yehudi Menuhin, outshines both, and Menuhin’s heart-rending 78, made during his early maturity in 1939, rather outshines Shaham’s, though to be fair it’s probably Menuhin’s most perfect single recording – quite an act to follow.
With fine engineering, realistically balanced, and excellent annotation, this is a digital front-runner, not forgetting the admirable Lionel Friedman whose sound and overall approach are on balance less distinctive than Shaham’s.
The symbiotic musical partnership of Hagai Shaham and Arnon Erez take that aggression as a starting point, but they also achieve a more inward communion for the work’s central Molto quieto. The Second Sonata follows Bartók’s Second in trading outward aggression for inward agitation and an earthy spirituality, folk-like in Bartók’s case (whose slow-fast pattern recalls Liszt’s and Bartók’s own Hungarian Rhapsodies), with Bloch more attuned to the world of prayer.
Bloch saw his Second Sonata as a fervid, idealistic counterbalance to the primordial onrush of his First, and the ecstatic harmonies that dominate the Second Sonata’s solo line have a profoundly prayerful effect. Shaham again scales the heights with mostly true intonation, a warm tone and meaty double-stops, though as soon as the first notes have sounded the searing benchmark of Jascha Heifetz inevitably invades the memory, more so than in the First Sonata, where the tender-hearted Louis Kaufman merits a special mention. That said, in both sonatas Shaham enjoys a more equal partnership with his pianists than Heifetz did.
The makeweights for this particular programme work well in context, Nuit exotique having a more eastern feel than the relatively modest Mélodie. Abodah (‘God’s Worship’), written for the child Yehudi Menuhin, outshines both, and Menuhin’s heart-rending 78, made during his early maturity in 1939, rather outshines Shaham’s, though to be fair it’s probably Menuhin’s most perfect single recording – quite an act to follow.
With fine engineering, realistically balanced, and excellent annotation, this is a digital front-runner, not forgetting the admirable Lionel Friedman whose sound and overall approach are on balance less distinctive than Shaham’s.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.

Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.