Benda, JA & F Violin Concertos
A stylishly performed collection of music by the Benda family – worth exploring
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Georg (Anton) Benda, Frantisek Benda
Genre:
Orchestral
Label: Naxos
Magazine Review Date: 13/2002
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 53
Mastering:
Stereo
DDD
Catalogue Number: 8 553994
Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Benda's Klagen |
Georg (Anton) Benda, Composer
Christian Benda, Cello Georg (Anton) Benda, Composer Prague Chamber Orchestra |
Concerto for Violin and Orchestra |
Frantisek Benda, Composer
Ariane Pfister, Violin Christian Benda, Conductor Frantisek Benda, Composer Suk Chamber Orchestra |
Concerto for Viola and Strings |
Georg (Anton) Benda, Composer
Christian Benda, Conductor Georg (Anton) Benda, Composer Josef Suk, Viola Suk Chamber Orchestra |
Author:
This is very much a family affair. The music is written by two Benda brothers of the mid18th century. It is conducted by a descendant‚ Christian Benda‚ who also has arranged one piece and plays it on the cello. One of the concertos is played by another descendant‚ Ariane Pfister; and the cadenzas played in that concerto are by her mother‚ Lola Benda. The other concerto is played by Josef Suk‚ who also comes from a Bohemian family of some musical repute (his greatgrandfather was Dvo·ák).
In fact‚ this Viola Concerto‚ played as immaculately and sonorously as it is here‚ is the most interesting item on the CD. There is some doubt as to which Benda actually composed it: out of the 12 family members entered in The New Grove‚ Friedrich Wilhelm Heinrich (17451814) and Friedrich Ludwig (175292) have also been suggested; but to my mind Georg (alias Ji·í Antonín – the initials used on the Naxos documentation – 172295) is the likeliest‚ for the style is very much that of the early galant and is decidedly conservative for c1775‚ the date proposed in the notes here.
Whoever composed it‚ and whenever they did so‚ it’s an attractive piece which knows where it’s going‚ strikes a warm and grave note in its central‚ minorkey Largo and resolves it happily in the minuetrondo that serves as finale. The work by his elder brother Franz (or FrantiÅek‚ 170986) is thought to be earlier and is still more conservative in manner‚ as well as rather more ordinary in its invention; it draws some graceful and quite eloquent playing from Pfister‚ especially in the central Affettuoso.
These are very much modern performances‚ stylish in their way but with no concessions to period techniques. The same goes‚ emphatically‚ for the performance of Benda’s Klagen‚ which was originally a sort of cantata for soprano and orchestra – it sounds well enough on the cello (and is surely and expressively played here)‚ but the music is full of gestures and musical figures that make sense only when associated with a text‚ and regrettably the original one is not printed here. But I suppose that a descendant of the composer may feel he has more right than most to misrepresent the music.
So on the whole I have enjoyed this CD‚ which confirms that Georg is the best of the Bendas – and perhaps that he was at his best in his fine melodramas‚ which Naxos have also recorded.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.
Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
SubscribeGramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.