Bach Mass in B minor
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Label: Veritas
Magazine Review Date: 8/1989
Media Format: Cassette
Media Runtime: 0
Mastering:
DDD
Catalogue Number: 759517-4

Label: Veritas
Magazine Review Date: 8/1989
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 107
Mastering:
DDD
Catalogue Number: 759517-2

Label: Veritas
Magazine Review Date: 8/1989
Media Format: Vinyl
Media Runtime: 0
Mastering:
DDD
Catalogue Number: 790757-1

Author: Nicholas Anderson
Compared with Harnoncourt's later version of the B minor Mass, Herreweghe makes a more favourable impression. His choir are or sound, considerably smaller, with seven sopranos divided into I and II, four altos (men and women), five tenors and five basses. The sound-quality is pleasing though not in fact enhanced by a close plummy balance. There are some fine solo instrumental contributions from the orchestra, too, although in ensemble I sometimes found the attack spongy and at times ragged. In matters of tempo and perhaps, too, in his general view of Bach's Mass, Herreweghe comes closer to Leonhardt's approach (EMI Deutsche Harmonia Mundi CDC169541-8, 12/86 nla) than to Parrott (EMI), Gardiner (Archiv Produktion) or the 1968 Harnoncourt version (also Teldec/ASV—transferred to CD and reviewed in 1986). The choruses are weighter than those of Parrott though by no means lacklustre, but I was dismayed at times by ragged ensemble (the opening of the Credo), rhythmic unsteadiness (''Confiteor''), and poor intonation (Sanctus). Tempos are moderately judged—safe would be one way of putting it, yet I very much like Herreweghe's expansive view of the music. He allows it time to breathe naturally and allows me time for reflection. In short, the supreme contemplative element in the music is seldom overlooked. The ''Domine Deus'' duet for soprano and tenor is a particularly good example of Herreweghe's relaxed manner. He allows the music to float ethereally with a natural respiratory rhythm, drawing affecting performances from Barbara Schlick, Howard Crook and Patrick Beuckels (flute). The second soprano Catherine Patriasz gives a pleasing performance of the ''Laudamus te'', though John Holloway in the Parrott recording and Elizabeth Wilcock in the John Eliot Gardiner one provide more winning violin obbligato accompaniments than that of Fransois Fernandez, whose playing lacks their poise and assurance. Charles Brett is convincing in the ''Qui sedes'' and affecting in the Agnus Dei and the bass, Peter Kooy is fluent and resonant in the ''Quoniam'' and ''Et in Spiritum Sanctum''.
My only serious reservation about Herreweghe's set concerns the sound of the recording itself. Many readers may not be bothered by the close balance but to my ears it is contrived, lacking the perspective which music on this scale requires. There is no way in which these forces could be gathered into the sort of drawing-room or ante-chamber implied by this acoustic. There is little or no space around the music and this has contributed towards a slight muddying of the textures, choral ones in particular. Musically, on the other hand, Herreweghe's view of the B minor Mass is largely convincing.
However, a clear recommendation of one version over another is somewhat pointless since most of the performances under discussion differ considerably in their aims and priorities. Andrew Parrott's recording remains top of my own list on account of the small forces, reduced but not 'ad absurdam', allowing for wonderfully transparent textures yet losing nothing in strength. Gardiner's version is impressive above all for the disciplined often exciting, choral singing and for Michaei Chance's Agnus Dei. Harnoncourt's earlier recording is alone among these in using boy trebles and altos in the choruses and Leonhardt is impressive for the way in which he conveys a strong sense of unity within the work. But Leonhardt's choir are disappointing and his soloists uneven, Herreweghe scores here with a uniformly strong solo group and a considerably abler choir though not equal to Gardiner's Monteverdi Choir or Parrott's Taverner Consort. Best of luck!'
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.

Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.