African Rhythms
A fascinating collision of music from three continents played with fiercesome dexterity
View record and artist detailsRecord and Artist Details
Composer or Director: Steve Reich, Traditional, György Ligeti
Genre:
Instrumental
Label: Teldec (Warner Classics)
Magazine Review Date: 10/2003
Media Format: CD or Download
Media Runtime: 51
Mastering:
Stereo
Catalogue Number: 8573-86584-2

Tracks:
Composition | Artist Credit |
---|---|
Etudes, Book 1, Movement: Fanfares |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer Pierre-Laurent Aimard, Piano |
Etudes, Book 2, Movement: Fém |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer Pierre-Laurent Aimard, Piano |
Etudes, Book 2, Movement: Entrelacs |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer Pierre-Laurent Aimard, Piano |
Etudes, Book 3, Movement: Pour Irina |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer Pierre-Laurent Aimard, Piano |
Etudes, Book 3, Movement: A bout de souffle |
György Ligeti, Composer
György Ligeti, Composer Pierre-Laurent Aimard, Piano |
Clapping Music |
Steve Reich, Composer
Pierre-Laurent Aimard, Percussion Steve Reich, Composer |
Music for Pieces of Wood |
Steve Reich, Composer
Pierre-Laurent Aimard, Piano Steve Reich, Composer |
Bossobe |
Traditional, Composer
Aka Pygmies Traditional, Composer |
Bobangi |
Traditional, Composer
Aka Pygmies Traditional, Composer |
Yangissa |
Traditional, Composer
Aka Pygmies Traditional, Composer |
Anduwa |
Traditional, Composer
Aka Pygmies Traditional, Composer |
Banga Banga |
Traditional, Composer
Aka Pygmies Traditional, Composer |
Zoboko |
Traditional, Composer
Aka Pygmies Traditional, Composer |
Mohunga |
Traditional, Composer
Aka Pygmies Traditional, Composer |
Mai |
Traditional, Composer
Aka Pygmies Traditional, Composer |
Author: mharry
Highlighting the première recordings of Etudes 16-18, this is the perfect remedy for over-exposure to Ligeti’s polyrhythms and abounds in thrilling contrasts. Above all, it sensitises the ear in a remarkable way to Ligeti’s innovations in phrasing and musical structure.
The Ligeti pieces are offset by two entirely different but significant elements. The first is the complex, predominantly vocal music of the Aka Pygmies from sub-Saharan Africa, a crucial structural element of which is an instrumenal ostinato in fast time, against which the voices set short-breathed phrases of irregular length.
The second element are Steve Reich’s Clapping Rhythm for two sets of hands, where the same rhythm is heard in different canonic relationships to itself, and Music For Pieces of Wood, which applies the processes of gradual rhythmic addition and subtraction to the same rhythmic pattern. Both techniques had consequences for Ligeti’s Etudes, but the implication of a direct relationship between Reich (who more likely drew his inspiration from Ghanaian Hunting music) and the Aka Pygmies is not quite right.
There are marvellous insights to be found in the juxtapositions here, moving in both directions: the effect of hearing Clapping Music followed by the Aka Pygmies’ Bobangi, where two pieces of iron hammer out a similar rhythm for its ostinato background, followed immediately by the ostinato of Ligeti’s Fourth Etude, which is in the same ‘key’ as Bobangi.
Aimard’s playing of the Ligeti is without parallel, but this is no surprise. Just as rewarding, though, are Clapping Music and Music For Pieces of Wood, where he is found clapping and playing overdubbed on himself. Inauthentic, perhaps, but by far the most exciting (and revealing) accounts of these two pieces I have ever heard.
At just 51 minutes, this disc is perfect for anybody hungry for a new kind of listening experience. It is also a perfect introduction to the very particular world of Ligeti’s piano études.
The Ligeti pieces are offset by two entirely different but significant elements. The first is the complex, predominantly vocal music of the Aka Pygmies from sub-Saharan Africa, a crucial structural element of which is an instrumenal ostinato in fast time, against which the voices set short-breathed phrases of irregular length.
The second element are Steve Reich’s Clapping Rhythm for two sets of hands, where the same rhythm is heard in different canonic relationships to itself, and Music For Pieces of Wood, which applies the processes of gradual rhythmic addition and subtraction to the same rhythmic pattern. Both techniques had consequences for Ligeti’s Etudes, but the implication of a direct relationship between Reich (who more likely drew his inspiration from Ghanaian Hunting music) and the Aka Pygmies is not quite right.
There are marvellous insights to be found in the juxtapositions here, moving in both directions: the effect of hearing Clapping Music followed by the Aka Pygmies’ Bobangi, where two pieces of iron hammer out a similar rhythm for its ostinato background, followed immediately by the ostinato of Ligeti’s Fourth Etude, which is in the same ‘key’ as Bobangi.
Aimard’s playing of the Ligeti is without parallel, but this is no surprise. Just as rewarding, though, are Clapping Music and Music For Pieces of Wood, where he is found clapping and playing overdubbed on himself. Inauthentic, perhaps, but by far the most exciting (and revealing) accounts of these two pieces I have ever heard.
At just 51 minutes, this disc is perfect for anybody hungry for a new kind of listening experience. It is also a perfect introduction to the very particular world of Ligeti’s piano études.
Discover the world's largest classical music catalogue with Presto Music.

Gramophone Digital Club
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £8.75 / month
Subscribe
Gramophone Full Club
- Print Edition
- Digital Edition
- Digital Archive
- Reviews Database
- Full website access
From £11.00 / month
Subscribe
If you are a library, university or other organisation that would be interested in an institutional subscription to Gramophone please click here for further information.