My first Gramophone review, by Rob Cowan
James McCarthy
Thursday, March 28, 2013
My first Gramophone review, Brahms and Khachaturian Violin Concertos with Henryk Szeryng and the LSO under Antal Doráti (on Mercury, 2/93), was a coming of age, even though I had been publishing reviews elsewhere for some years. I was in fact a phoenix that rose from the flames of Classics, a Gramophone magazine that I edited (with Andrew Achenbach as my trusty assistant) for its all-too-brief run of 11 issues. Gramophone though was ‘the bizz’, the perceived gold standard, and writing for her was a palpable wish fulfilment. As a devoted reader since childhood I was immensely proud to have been selected by James Jolly, even though the kudos of being included in the highlighted critics’ panel was still a month away.
Looking at that fairly innocuous review now (see below), I see nothing in particular that’s wrong with it. I’ve written better – and worse – since, and the critical evaluation still holds, certainly within the context of its time. But 20 years of further listening (and reading) have helped sharpen my critical responses and I like to think that I’m a better reviewer now than I was then. The big difference is that in those days I held idolatrous views of certain artists and entertained some fairly fixed opinions, whereas nowadays it’s more a case of evaluating each recording on its own terms. Comparisons, yes; preconceptions, no. Much healthier.
Brahms Violin Concerto Khachaturian Violin Concerto
Henryk Szeryng vn London Symphony Orchestra / Antal Doráti
Mercury Living Presence 434 318-2MM (73' • ADD) (Buy from Amazon)
Szeryng's three commercial recordings of the Brahms Concerto have each featured strong accompaniments, but Doráti's – which marries muscle and breadth with a fine sense of structural balance – is in many ways the finest. Szeryng himself is able to soften or strengthen his instrument's voice according to the dictates of the score, a virtue that is tellingly illustrated in his playing of Joachim's first-movement cadenza. The Khachaturian, too, is vital and forthright, and here Doráti's natural feel for the music's balletic character pays high dividends: sample his taut handling of the third movement's Goyaneh-style opening tutti, where a crack 1964 LSO charges at the notes like a band of angry Cossacks. It's a tuneful and engaging piece and the Szeryng/Doráti partnership relishes its every colourful detail; what's more, the engineers capture both works in keen, forwardly-balanced sound. The transfers are truthful to the original tapes, hiss and all.
Rob Cowan (Gramophone, February 1993)
Tweet